From Spotlight: Stay Healthy at Home — It’s as Easy as Saying Ahhh

In Defense of Having a (Slightly) Cluttered Home

A messy environment is actually good for your psyche.

Cluttered mess in teenage bedroom of a home
Image: mixetto/Getty

Breaking news: Humans like stuff. Stuff they have. Stuff they like. Stuff they need.

But stuff just gets everywhere. Hence the trendiness of uber-organized spaces, hyper-cleanliness, and Marie Kondo-like thank-your-stuff-for-its-service-then-toss-it attitudes. But living in that state of constant tidying is exhausting.

Enough.

It is not a moral failing to have a slightly cluttered home.

And you know what? Life can be better with slightly more stuff. Here are seven reasons why:

#1 A Messy Environment Is a More Creative One

Being too tidy will stifle your imagination. Science says so.

There's a lot of research showing messy surroundings encourage you to break the rules of convention and think more freely, while a highly ordered house stifles you.

We're not talking rooms full of empty cat food cans and closets crammed with so much crap you can't open the door. We're talking about a comfortable amount of disorder.

If you're not convinced disarray fuels creativity, Google "Einstein's office." He dreamed up the theory of relativity in a room that would give Marie Kondo a heart attack.

If you share your home, chat with your partner and agree on the line between acceptable clutter and chaos. Is the pile of shoes in your overflowing collection a sign you're a trendsetter or a sign you're a hoarder? Discuss.

#2 A Perfectly Tidy Home Isn't a Sign of a Happy Home

Your obituary won't mention how tidy your house was (unless you're Martha), so why dedicate your life to cleaning it?

"Your home will never be 100% clean and organized and lived in at the same time," says Becky Rapinchuk, author of "Simply Clean."

You want to focus on living in your home, keeping it functional and enjoyable — not perfect.

She recommends doing one task each day: Clean bathrooms Monday, dust on Tuesdays. You get it.

This allows you time to do the things that remind you why you bought your house, from porch swinging to reading-nook sitting. "Don't spend more than 30 minutes a day on each task," Rapinchuk says.

"If you don't get it done, save it until next week. It's just dirt."

#3 A Little Dirt Is Good for You

People with super-clean houses have bleached and scrubbed all the microbes out of their house. But some of those microbes sent to that petri dish in the sky are actually good for you.

They strengthen your immune system and make your kids less likely to develop allergies.

A study showed that infants exposed to cleaning products in the first three months of life were more likely to develop asthma by age three. For adults, another study found the use of cleaning sprays at least weekly was associated with asthma symptoms and use of medication.

The solution? Use natural cleaning products free of industrial chemicals.

And don't clean so much. And maybe add a bit more clutter (and dirt) with plants.

#4 Plant-Cluttered Houses Are Healthier Houses

Sure, houseplants drop leaves and look unruly at times, and their pots scatter dirt. But you'll breathe easier around them and possibly live longer, too.

Many houseplants remove toxins from the air (devil's ivy and peace lily are two examples).

And studies have shown that having a bit of nature indoors reduces the type of stress that causes deadly cardiovascular problems.

Plus, filling your home with houseplants is so trendy right now, a la #urbanjungle.

#5 If You Do Declutter, You'll Toss Something You Need Later

Disciples of extreme cleaning and organizing exclaim how happy they are to be free of their stuff. At first.

"All kinds of wonderful, valuable, and useful things get thrown out in the name of organizing," writes Columbia Business School professor Eric Abrahamson in his book (with David H. Freedman)  “A Perfect Mess."

Instead of throwing out anything you haven't used in a year, Abrahamson recommends evaluating an item's value and ability to be replaced. Throw out that stack of Domino back issues. Think twice about tossing your first edition "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone."

#6 A Cluttered Home Can Be Stylish, Too

The backlash to minimalism has begun. Thank goodness.

Evidence? Jungalow style, a look that features rooms stuffed with artful clutter: houseplants everywhere, boho pillows, tribal rugs, mismatched furniture, tchotchkes on every flat surface, and walls full of macramé hangings and art. Your clutter is no longer clutter. It's fashion.

#7 The Stuff You Love Isn't Clutter

It's your stuff. Don't let the cleaning and decluttering tyrants tell you what's clutter and what's not. Make your house please you.

Fill it with items that mean something to you and express your personality. Display your 25-year-old T-ball trophy, make a gallery wall of your child's art, and stack your vintage vinyl collection on the mid-century mod end table you snagged at a garage sale.

Throw away the copy of “The Art of Tidying Up" that you bought in a moment of guilt. Now that's clutter.

Related: 7 Sneaky Storage Ideas to Hide Your Clutter in Plain Sight

A headshot of Leanne Potts
Leanne Potts

Leanne Potts is an Atlanta-based journalist and serial home remodeler. She's tackled five fixer-uppers and is working on a sixth. She's written about everything from forest fires to dog-friendly decor and spent a decade leading the digital staff of HGTV.